27 °F Ocean City, US
December 5, 2025

Four newcomers elected to Ocean City school board, ousting incumbents

Upper Township returns two incumbents and their running mate

Four newcomers were elected to the Ocean City Board of Education Tuesday and two incumbents and their running mate were chosen by voters in the Upper Township school board race, according to unofficial results.

In Ocean City, Catherine Panico, Kevin Barnes and Liz Nicoletti won three-year terms and Robin Shaffer won the one-year unexpired term.

Incumbent school board President Dr. Patrick Kane and fellow board members Dr. Charles Roche and Greg Whelan did not win new terms. Ryan Leonard, who was appointed to the board on August, lost his bid for the one-year term.

In Upper Township, long-serving members Michele Barbieri and Kristie Chisholm were re-elected. Their running mate, Christine Lentz, won the other three-year term.

Incumbent William Sooy lost his bid for re-election in the large field of candidates.

Barbieri earned 2,219 votes, Lentz received 2,208 and Chisholm got 2,109.

Daniel Kilgallon was close behind with 2,016 followed by Kiernan Black with 1,909. Alexander Grassi had 1,629 and Sooy had 1,033.

In Ocean City, Panico received the most votes with 2,259 followed by running mate Nicoletti with 2,082. Barnes won the third three-year term with 2,062 votes.

Kane received 2,027, Roche had 1,824 and Whelan 1,664.

For the one-year term, Shaffer, who campaigned with Panico and Nicoletti, won with 2,079 votes.

Leonard received 1,398 and the third candidate, former board member Dale Braun, got 636 votes.

Panico, Nicoletti and Shaffer all lost their bids running for school board last year, as did Leonard and Braun.

Unlike Braun and Leonard, however, the trio have been outspoken over the past year at school board meetings. They raised issues during public comment, most of it spent assailing the new state Board of Education Health and Physical Education standards school boards across New Jersey had to adopt.

Panico, Shaffer and Nicoletti, along with others, repeatedly urged the board to reject the standards, complaining they included language and content about sex education, sexuality and gender identity inappropriate for students, especially in the lower grades.

The board narrowly adopted the standards in August in a 6-5 vote, after educators explained the district was able to tailor the curriculum around the standards to fit the community.  

The educators said Ocean City’s curriculum removed the controversial content and in matters of sex education, sexuality, gender and gender identity, if students wanted to go beyond the parameters of the curriculum, teachers would tell them to go home and ask their parents.

The voting results in this story are from the capemaycountyvotes.com website run by the county clerk’s office.

By DAVID NAHAN/Sentinel Staff

Related articles

Democrats make case for CD-2

CAPE MAY COURT HOUSE – There was more agreement than sparring as Democratic candidates for the Second Congressional District outlined their positions at a public forum last week. The Middle Township Democratic Club sponsored the March 4 candidate’s forum held at the Old Cape May Court House. Candidates answered questions from moderators Jim Quinn, Lenora […]

Plurality rules in New Jersey

Ranked-choice voting would ensure majority support OCEAN CITY — Should a candidate have to secure a majority (more than half) of votes to win an election in New Jersey? That’s the question advocates of rank-choice voting are asking as they push back against line voting, which they say favors particular candidates over others and can […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *