27 °F Ocean City, US
December 5, 2025

Sea Isle police officers allegedly assaulted during domestic violence call

SEA ISLE CITY – Three Pennsylvania men allegedly assaulted Sea Isle City police officers when they responded to a 911 call Monday, July 18, at 6001 Central Ave., (North Unit), for a report of domestic violence. 

When the officers arrived, the accused allegedly attempted to lock the officers out of the rental property, while victims were requesting help, Capt. Anthony J. Garreffi Jr. said in a press release issued Tuesday.

He said officers forced their way in and were immediately allegedly assaulted by three family members. Three officers were injured during the incident and required medical treatment at Cape Regional Medical Center in Cape May Court House. One officer sustained a broken fibula bone during the altercation, and the two other officers received minor injuries, he said. All three officers were treated and released from the hospital.  All three defendants refused medical treatment.

The defendants were charged with the following crimes and all three remain in the Cape May County Correction Center pending Detention Hearings:

Robert G. Watmuff, Sr., 64, of West Chester, Pa.:

–Five (5) Counts of Aggravated Assault on Police, Third Degree;

– Resisting Arrest, Third Degree;

– Obstruction, Fourth Degree;

– Conspiracy to Aggravated Assault (2C )(Non DV), Second Degree;

– Domestic Violence Strangulation, Second Degree;

–  Domestic Violence Aggravated Assault, Second Degree;

– Domestic Violence Criminal Restraint, Third Degree;

– Domestic Violence Terroristic Threats, Third Degree; and

– Domestic Violence Simple Assault, Disorderly Persons Offense.

Robert Watmuff, Jr., 41, of Malvern, Pa.:

–Five (5) Counts of Aggravated Assault on Police, Third Degree;

– Resisting Arrest, Third Degree;

– Obstruction, Fourth Degree;

– Conspiracy to Aggravated Assault (2C )(Non DV), Second Degree;

–  Domestic Violence Aggravated Assault, Second Degree;

–  Domestic Violence Aggravated Assault, Third Degree;

Colin Watmuff, 23, of West Chester, Pa.:

– Four (4) Counts of Aggravated Assault on Police, Third Degree.

This incident is currently under investigation by the Sea Isle City Police Department. More criminal charges may follow.

Second Degree crimes carry a maximum penalty of 10 years in New Jersey State Prison. Third Degree crimes carry a maximum penalty of 5 years in New Jersey State Prison.

The defendants are presumed innocent unless or until they are proven guilty.

By DAVID NAHAN/Sentinel staff

Related articles

Ocean City’s ‘Swingin’ Into the Holidays’ back on stage Dec. 10-12

OCEAN CITY — This season the Greater Ocean City Theatre Company invites the public to celebrate the most wonderful time of the year at “Swingin’ into the Holidays,” Ocean City’s holiday spectacular. Artistic Director Michael Hartman said the OCTC is thrilled to bring the show back to the Music Pier after a one-year hiatus due to […]

Summer parking remains an issue in Strathmere

By BILL BARLOW/Special to the Sentinel STRATHMERE – Traffic crawls on summer weekends in the shore town section of Upper Township, with drivers taking care to watch for pedestrians, car doors opening and more along the narrow streets.  In some areas, when cars are parked along both sides of the road, the route is tight […]

1 Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *