28 °F Ocean City, US
December 5, 2025

OCHS Drama Guild presents ‘Peter and the Starcatcher’

OCEAN CITY — The Ocean City High School Drama Guild is set to present “Peter and the Starcatcher” on stage Nov. 20-22 at the Bill and Nancy Hughes Performing Arts Center.

Performances are scheduled for 6:30 p.m. each evening.

Director Ellen Byrne said the play “invites you to come aboard as we meet a Boy, his orphan companions and a precocious girl named Molly who sail the high seas, fight pirates, survive a shipwreck, discover a tribal nation and sing with mermaids, while protecting a dangerous treasure.”

The play is based on the 2004 novel by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson, adapted for the stage by Rick Elice. It serves as a prequel to “Peter and Wendy” by J.M. Barrie, providing a backstory for the characters of Peter Pan, Mrs. Darling, Tinker Bell and Captain Hook.

Bryne, serving as director for the first time following the resignation of Robert LeMaire in the spring, has been costume designer and assistant director for years.

“The whole premise of the play is supposed to be using your imagination to build the world that you play in,” Byrne said. “The way I’ve had the kids trying to think about it is to harken back to those days when we were little kids and you went out in the neighborhood with all your friends and you didn’t have much in the way of fancy toys. You had a couple of empty boxes and an old Christmas tree. So ‘Peter and the Starcatcher’ is a story made with minimal things.”

Freshman Henry Costal stars as Boy, aka Peter. The Marmora resident has been acting since fifth grade. Along with his twin sister Tallulah, he follows older brother Charlie Costal, who was a star of the stage for four years at OCHS.

Tallulah Costal, who portrays Hawking Clam, said she is so happy to be part of the theater.

“I’m so excited. I’ve been looking forward to being a part of the Drama Guild for so long and it’s everything I thought it would be and more,” she said. “I’m having just the best time. 

Describing the play as “kind of crazy,” Henry said his character is an orphan being sent off to work for the king, “but really, he’s going to try and eat me. He’s going to feed me to his snakes and I end up escaping and making it to this island, which becomes the island of the Lost Boys where they stay in ‘Peter Pan.’”

“There’s magic, fighting, jumping, falling in the water, star stuff,” Costal said, boasting that he does his own stunts. “I jump off one of the stairs of the platform at one time and we have a little slide thing that I slide down. It’s cool.”

Costal said the rehearsal process has been terrific. 

“I’ve made a lot of new friends and it’s been really great being able to work as leads with other seniors who are leaving next year and just making friends who are so much older than me,” he said, noting his favorite thing about being in theater is “being able to express yourself through different characters and truly bringing characters to life and putting them on the stage.”

Outside the theater, he enjoys biking and golfing with friends but “I’m always just either singing, dancing, acting, you know, a lot of everything I do sort of is based around theater.”

Sophomore Ingrid Pohlig is the play’s female lead, Molly, who is the mother of Wendy in ‘Peter Pan.’

Molly meets Peter Pan before Wendy and teaches him to fly.

“She kind of like saves his life at a couple points and guides him through becoming Peter Pan,” Costal said.

Pohlig is looking forward to the performances.

“I think it’s really fun because theres a lot of nice, really funny jokes in it but it’s still kind of centered toward all ages,” she said.

Performing in her first major role, the Ventnor resident said she is nervous but also excited.

“I feel really grateful and I’m just working really hard,” Pohlig said.

Costal said the partnership has evolved from the beginning of rehearsals.

“Being leads together, we’ve had to grow like as a friendship,” he said. “I’ve been just getting to know her.”

Pohlig said she enjoys the Drama Guild “because I get to see all my friends and then we get to work through scenes together and if there’s a problem, we solve it.”

She said her favorite part of the play is “the set and I like how we use props to kind of make it come alive.”

The set features the deck of a wooden sailing ship and is a constant throughout the production.

“It’s a play that really uses the imagination,” Pohlig said.

Narrators, dressed in black and situated off to the side, play a prominent role in the play, with one serving for each major character.

Rhyan Wilkin, narrator for Molly, said they “try to tell the story to the audience but directly, they kind of replicate the characters that they’re trying to do the narration.”

Ocean City resident Sean Wilde said he really enjoys playing his character, the orphan Prentiss, whom he called “very snarky, very sarcastic.” 

Senior Noah Baker, who plays a convincing Black Stache, said he likes getting to play off cousin Christian Hornig-Finneran.

“They’ve pretty much given us the steering wheel to the ship and given us great freedom to experiment with the characters,” Baker said.

Cast

Henry Costal: Boy/Peter

Ingrid Pohlig: Molly

Elizabeth Louis: Mrs. Bumbrake

Sam Lowe: Lord Aster

Sean Wilde: Prentiss

Hanna Dolinsky: Smee

Andrew Pelaez: Fighting Prawn

Taylor Mulford: Teacher

Adam Wertzberger: Mack

Noah Baker: Black Stache

Ruby Scott: Grempkin

Christian Hornig-Finneran: Slank

Jackson Mulford: Capt. Scott

Lily Pettit: Ted

Brodie Madison: Alf

Tallulah Costal: Hawking Clam

Ike Thompson: Sanchez

Nathan Lera, Ryhan Wilkin, Julia Colangelo, Cooper Lloyd, Tegan Goodwin, Hannah Oliver, Addison Bradshaw, Michaela Voegtlin, Violet Knapp, Sydney Chin, Reina Xu, Logan Moore, Sydney Burwell: narrators

British Navy sailors, Neverland crew, pirates, orphans, mermaids and mollusks — Tim Arsenault, Olivia Baez, James Brown, Cassidy Campanella, Hannah Cavileer, Emily Ferretti, Alyssa Hopson, Ellie Levick, Olivia Morgan, Braden Rementer, Madelyn Saul, Brynn Sulick and Bryan Vandever

Student stage managers — Morgan Dougan, Scarlett Garrett and Addison Guest

Student director — Tegan Goodwin

Student choreographer — Reina Xu

Student vocal director — Taylor Mulford

Dramaturg — Emma Saul

By CRAIG D. SCHENCK/Sentinel staff

Related articles

YoungLife students think beyond themselves, act

By DAVID NAHAN/Sentinel staff OCEAN CITY – Just before Thanksgiving, students from YoungLife and WyldLife gathered at Tabernacle Baptist Church in Ocean City to think beyond themselves and to act. “We are putting together shoeboxes for the ministry, Samaritan’s Purse, for Operation Christmas, and also for Crisis Pregnancy Services in Egg Harbor City to show […]

Children Academy is going up after Northfield Plaza comes down

NORTHFIELD — American Demolition reduced the former Northfield Plaza building to a pile of rubble in December to make way for Children Academy Childcare & Learning Center. “We’re getting there, we’re very excited,” said Liz Palmer, who runs similar centers in Egg Harbor and Galloway townships with her husband, Olufemi. Work has moved quickly; the […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *